pilot vs pilot – poll

47 Comments

1. Both are excellent … I decided to be raw

   1

   • it was a pretty solid foundation

     • Good substrate and good contrast

       1

       • I might play with her more tonight…

         • And what are you going to add?

           1

2. I like both pics equally.

   1

   • I wish my clients were more like you

3. Again a great job. I decided to be cruel, though they are both fantastic

   1

   • In what way were you cruel?

     1

     • I’m sorry, I made a mistake. I decided to crude and not cruel

       1

       • that makes so much more sense, you don’t strike me as someone who would be casually cruel…

4. sis know best, pick the post one.

   1

   • it is a nice effect, I am just worried about the edges…

5. I love the post version, but the raw version captures her outfit slightly more.

   1

   • this post technique softens, which kills detail…

     1

     • I love the tone of her skin in it though

       1

       • soft filter / glamour shots are generally flattering to the skin, which is why we use them…

         1

6. Loving that helmet she is wearing

   1

   • it is quite a bit of fun, is it not?

     1

     • Reminds me of the movie Punisher, which just so happens to be a favorite of mines

       1

       • the iconography is quite similar

         1

         • That is yet another theme that would really make my day if I saw it created by you.

           1

7. You said do you have any concerns please leave them in the comments

   I am concerned that the two left-handed people in my house are trying to take over the world.

   1

   • they’re out-numbered, I wouldn’t worry about it…

     1

     • It is 50 50 in my house.

       I sleep with one eye open!

       Thanks for the opened ended comment request 🙂

       1

       • thanks for taking advantage of it

8. I prefer the pale one on the left because I can relate to her. ?
   Just kidding, her skin feels more real on the raw.
   I usually prefer the dark, but I agree with you about the black outfit mixing with the dark background.

   1

   • I need to address that issue

     1

9. Chose the right one but wold like to see more of her eyes.

   1

   • another major flaw in this piece

10. Somehow I liked the raw … I tried hard to see difference between the 2…
    I only saw the darker shadows … and probably skin colour …

    I would like those eyes… don’t block them too much 🙂

    1

    • I won’t make that mistake again in the rework…

11. Well, if I am a guy, I would ride any spaceship or plane she would fly regardless if it is going to Pluto ?. Can you please pull down a bit that mask thing she is wearing to show bit more of lips and the flesh right under the lower lip ? and no, I am not trying to annoy you btw

    2

    • it’s a valid observation, and a reasonable request

12. I went with the post version since the skin tone looks nicer.

    1

    • skintones seem to be a dividing factor in this piece…

      • That is true based on the poll answers.

        1

        • I am most likely changing the pose anyway

          • That is fine with me since it is your artwork.

            1

13. it is less saturated and a bit lighter

    1

    • so you prefer the richer blue?

      1

    • you’re going to make baby blue self-conscious

      1

14. I might be paranoid again, it happens…

    1

    • worried the piece is too dark when it isn’t

      1

15. Again interesting and amazing poll. Post I like , I mean right one

    2

    • yeah, that way is just more fun

    • I am glad to hear you like it. I want to play with it a bit more