Love ItLove It

Discussion About Meat vs Soybeans

Recently, a vegan was trying to argue that soybeans were as good as meat in regard to protein. While I respect his opinion, I can’t agree with it. Here is why:

There are a few plants that are relatively high in protein. Soybeans are one of these. Most other plants are high in carbohydrates and low in protein.

What is important is that protein to carbohydrate ratio. Protein is needed for building healthy muscle mass. Excess Carbs are easily converted to fat. Diabetics are also warned to stay away from carbs. The problem is that high-protein plants often also contain a lot of carbs. For instance, a cup of soybeans has about 12.95 g of protein. This is among the highest in edible plants and it is indeed a high-protein source. However, a cup of soybeans also contains 11 g of carbohydrates. Soybeans also lack several essential amino acids, but that is beside the point I’m making.

In comparison, 3 oz of beef contains 22 g of protein and 0 g of carbohydrates. Soybeans don’t come close to this. Beef is higher in calories, but the protein-carbohydrate ratio is far better, depending on what else is eaten. Beef does contain the essential amino acids soybeans lack, but again, that isn’t the point.

Perhaps an even bigger point is this: What a person decides to eat is entirely up to them. Since it is a personal choice, it is neither right or wrong. But, please don’t tell me that soybeans are as good as meat. t that point, it becomes entirely subjective and based on opinion, rather than fact.

  • Have you ever had someone tell you that soybeans were as good as or better than meat?

    • Yes
    • No


What do you think?

11 Points

Written by Rex Trulove


    • I’ve noticed that. I don’t begrudge them the choice to eat nothing but plants if that is what they want to eat. I simply draw the line at giving false information in an attempt to justify a personal choice that doesn’t need to be justified since it is a personal choice.

      • Statistics is one of the 1000 ways to twist facts. Soybeans do have high amount of protein ,the other facts were glossed over. Similarly there will be many facts which r being glossed over for meats. So just choose your poison.