in

Love ItLove It

Should ancient treasures be repatriated?

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

The world’s top museums are home to some wonderful treasures that have been seen by millions of people down the centuries, but there is a huge question mark hanging over many of these artefacts, namely whether they should be there at all. Should they go back to their countries of origin?

There are many famous objects that fall into this category, and here are just a few examples:

The Elgin Marbles

In 1801 the Earl of Elgin visited Athens and took a fancy to the frescoes that lined the top of the Parthenon building that dominates the Acropolis. Greece was then part of the Ottoman Empire, and Elgin persuaded the appropriate officials to let him chip off the frescoes and take them back to London, where they have been one of the top exhibits at the British Museum ever since.

But should they go back to Greece? One argument has always been that the frescoes would have suffered severe damage from atmospheric pollution had they stayed where they were, and that there was nowhere in Athens that was suitable for their display. However, these problems no longer apply.

The Ishtar Gate (see photo)

This was the entrance to the ancient city of Babylon, built around 575 BC on the orders of King Nebuchadnezzar. It lay in ruins under desert sand for many centuries until discovered by a German team of archaeologists prior to World War I. They shipped all the pieces back to Berlin, where it was reconstructed inside the Pergamon Museum.

The modern state of Iraq built a replica gate on the original site, but would dearly love to be able to replace it with the real thing.

The Koh-I-Noor Diamond

This is a massive diamond that weighs 105 carats, making it one of the largest in the world. It was found in an Indian mine and was proudly owned by the Mughal emperors until the British took over India and the diamond became the property of Queen Victoria after the conquest of the Punjab in 1849. It was set into one of the crowns worn by British royalty and now forms part of the Crown Jewels on display at the Tower of London.

There is a problem with any potential repatriation of the Koh-I-Noor, namely where should it go to? It is claimed by India, Pakistan and Afghanistan!

Priam’s Treasure

This is a collection of Bronze Age jewellery and weaponry that was excavated in 1873 by the German archaeologist Heinrich Schliemann from what he mistakenly believed to be the ruins of the City of Troy that featured in Homer’s Iliad. The treasures were taken to Berlin where they stayed until World War II when they were looted by the Soviet Russians in 1945 as they swept into Hitler’s capital city.

The argument was that Russia was entitled to take the treasure as part compensation for the destruction wrought by Germany on Soviet cities during the war. It is now on display in Moscow’s Pushkin State Museum of Fine Arts. But where should the treasure go now? Back to Berlin, or possibly to Turkey where it originated?

  • Question of

    In general terms, should all museum treasures go back to where they came from?

    • Yes
    • No
  • Question of

    Should treasures be returned only when requested by their original home country?

    • Yes
    • No
  • Question of

    Where should the Elgin Marbles be displayed?

    • London
    • Athens
  • Question of

    Where should the Ishtar Gate be displayed?

    • Berlin
    • Iraq
  • Question of

    Where should the Koh-I-Noor diamond be displayed?

    • London
    • India
    • Pakistan
    • Afghanistan
  • Question of

    Where should Priam’s Treasure be displayed?

    • Moscow
    • Berlin
    • Turkey

Report

What do you think?

14 points
Legend

Written by Indexer

Story MakerQuiz MakerYears Of MembershipVerified UserContent Author

10 Comments

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply