The number of birds in the world is decreasing at an alarming rate. The many conservation groups around the world are concerned. Scientists continue to study the issue, and they as well are alarmed. The interesting reality of this issue is the disinformation that has been thrown doubt over the past two years. The first one is that Wind Turbines kill more birds than anything (they don’t). Wind Turbines are way down the list. Now, if some of the power company goals are achieved, there will be 10 to 20 times as many wind farms in the world as there are today. The problem with that is, they would still crack the top five in terms of overall birds killed.
The other often throws out the killer of birds is Windows. While yes, windows do kill birds. You would have to combine windows, wind turbines, solar farms, and human hunters even to be close to the number of birds killed by Domestic Cats. That, by the way, is not even close to the number of birds killed by feral cats. But the disinformation campaign continues to spread around the world like a giant oozing oil spill.
Oh yeah, oil spills are bad for wildlife, but it doesn’t represent a huge killer of birds.
There are 2.9 billion birds missing, no longer flying, no longer appearing in pictures shared on Virily now than there were 30 years ago. One of the things that are impacting the birds is Climate Change. In fact, on the links below there are a couple of articles that look at the death of birds (and frogs) and project that out as an indicator of just how bad climate change is.
I do worry about the misinformation – I have heard wind turbines, solar arrays and windows all used in a variety of unverified presentations. Because of that, I include links to validated scientific articles below. These include US government agencies (USGS) showing the population shifts by region in the US. Plus, references to the study showing 2.9 billion fewer birds in the US.
Finally, there is a link to a table that is roughly nine years old. I will continue to look for the updated version. Contrary to the Window claim, the Wind Turbine Claim, Feral, and Domestic cats are the only human-created problem on the list of bird killers that kill birds at a single-digit rate compared to the other things that kill birds.
Links (that support and provide facts)
https://www.mbr-pwrc.usgs.gov/bbs/guild/group.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/19/opinion/crisis-birds-north-america.html
https://sora.unm.edu/sites/default/files/journals/nab/v043n02/p00260-p00270.pdf
-
Question of
It is really sad so many birds are gone forever, right?
-
Yes
-
No
-
-
Question of
as authors we are responsible for making sure we don’t publish disinformation, right?
-
Yes
-
No
-
-
Question of
Will you read the articles on the links?
-
Yes
-
No
-
-
Question of
I promise I am not anti-cat, ok?
-
Yes
-
No
-
Well, I can only speak for New Zealand..bird deaths here are caused by cats, ferrets, weasels, stoats, car accidents, windows, rats, mice, opossums…
Up to human population, our New Zealand birds had no natural predators, and since people arrived our bird life has been under threat.
It is a sad reality. There is so much disinformation out on the internet about what kills birds it makes me sad.
I promised myself not to get frustrated about the disinformation but I can’t help it. Climate change is the probably biggest cause of killing birds. But Cats are right there!
Q: It is really sad so many birds are gone forever, right?
Yes (6 votes) – 100%
Q: as authors we are responsible for making sure we don’t publish disinformation, right?
Yes (5 votes) – 100%
Q: Will you read the articles on the links?
Yes (3 votes) – 60%
No (2 votes) – 40%
Q: I promise I am not anti-cat, ok?
Yes (5 votes) – 100%
Republicans trying to blame avian depopulation on alternative energy is like Charlie Mansion trying to pin the Tate murders on the police…
hell, that’s pretty much a 1:1 correspondence ratio!
I read the “windows” kill more birds than cats post earlier yesterday. The disinformation out there is terrifying.
I wish I could yes, yes it simply one group doing this.
But it isn’t, its the anti-climate change people.
It the anti-wind turbine people.
It the pro-cat people.
We are the cause. Humans. We caused this mess.
the windows post is just more cat apologist propaganda deliberately put out by the pro cat media in a desperate attempt to shift the blame away from the feline perpetrators…
yes, but the if not cats, then
title make me very sad.
The reality is humans are responsible. We put cats where they are.
that’s true. but then we can trace most issues with the planet back to humans, if not directly then at least indirectly. this would be the latter case…
yes the study (2.9 billion less birds in the US alone in the last 30 years) talks about the following impacts:
Cats
climate change
It makes me sad when I see the apologists throwing about facts that aren’t well, facts.
what was that idiotic term? “alternate facts” as if I can’t recognize that as code for lies…
yes i had forgotten about alternate facts.
I haven’t been that pissed off since “we don’t have an exit strategy”
I wonder if the interest isn’t killing information. Strangling it slowly with the ever-increasing new names for disinformation.
if only politicians were endangered or extinct…
There are good politicians on both sides of the aisle. Ones that care for the people of their districts and states.
I think the time has come to overhaul our system.
the aisle shouldn’t even be there to begin with. so I agree that the system needs to be replaced with something that works for the people…
I honestly think it is time for the American people to do our half the bargain. over the last 100 years, our participation rate in elections has continued to slide. If you have a vote, use it!
people shouldn’t fear their government, governments should fear their people…
I would love it if it were more of a true partnership – neither fear the other and works together.
Ask not what your country can do for you.
Ask what you can do for your country.
JFK.
where there is inequality there will be anger and fear
In our country we have in the construction of wind turbines greatest difficulties precisely because of the birds. As a result, construction in some places completely stopped.
that is why the studies were done. The cats walking around (feral) will kill more birds in a month in your country than wind turbines will in a year.
It is a very sad disinformation campaign.
I agree. But cats are very popular so no one will “admit it”
Plus there are many disinformation campaigns going on. I worry when I see them because it leaves people no chance.
Knowing what is happening around us shouldn’t require us to research in the information presented to us, every time.
I am a cat lover and know they are killing birds. Thankfully mine are indoor cats.
You are a responsible (loving) cat owner Carol! It is important that you get kudos for that!!!!
Thank you Doc, and I always rescue my pets so they are not put down.
That is also a wonderful thing you do!
One with one another and the number of birds and other animals is really decreasing, dear friend … you think the cats are the ones who kill the most birds
Scientists have studied and shown that cats kill the vast majority of birds. The number of domestic and feral cats has increased over the last 100 years. The reality is humans are responsible either way (we are the ones that have, and abandon cats).
If you say so you surely believe it, dear friend …. you know I am in the country and there are many cats and I have never seen one to catch a bird … I don’t think he even knows … or a mouse
9 billion – that is what cats kill every single year.
9 billion
windows are 900 million
Wind turbines are around 500 million
all told cats are the number one issue.
Cats are obviously the biggest danger to birds, my friend
sadly they are, but of course, humans are the reason cats are all over. I love cats! My daughter has the sweetest cat at her house.
It’s not only birds; so many species of nature creatures are also disappearing now.
that is true, the issue that came up is the reality of cats killing birds. The destruction of nature is an effect of climate change, and that is also horrific!
There are many things that affect the bird population. It is a fact that facilities that impede their migration – wind turbines or power lines – are being built along the migration routes.
One of the main roads – Via Pontica, passes through Bulgaria.
A powerful power line passes through it and 23 storks were killed by an electric shock this fall when they flew through it.
Urbanization also destroys nesting sites.
This also applies to other wildlife suffering from excessive human activity.
those are all sad, but true. However, the reality is that in fact, cats both domestic and feral do far more damage to bird populations.