Metal Roof Vs Asphalt Shingle Roof: Which One To Choose For Roofing In 2020

If you’re building a new house or planning to remodel your old house, choosing which roof will work the best for you and your house will be a daunting task. There are a lot of choices when it comes to roofing. So, you need to be careful when it comes to roofs.

There are without a doubt a lot of factors to be considered when deciding what to put on your roof. A lot of time you might have read about “metal roof vs Asphalt shingle roof”, right? Each one of the following has its Pros and Cons.

Metal Roof Vs Asphalt Shingle Roof: Which Is Better? 

Below, we have outlined the advantages and disadvantages of the metal roof and asphalt roof. So, keep reading until the end of this article and make a sound decision.

Advantages – Asphalt Shingle Roof 

1: Easy Installation:

The asphalt shingle roofs are time and cost-savvy. Yes, the installation requires less time and labor force. Did you know that the shingle roofs come prepackaged and they only need to nail to the deck?

2: Inexpensive Repair:

The metal roof repair is more complex than asphalt shingle roofs because the panels are connected. However, the damaged shingles can easily be removed one at a time from the source of the deck.

3: Availability:

The asphalt shingle roofs are commonly sold at local retailers and hardware stores. Keep in mind that the availability of the shingle roof depends upon where you live.

Disadvantages – Asphalt Shingle Roof

1: Short Life Cycle:

No matter the material and coating you choose when it comes to asphalt shingle roofs, the life of the roof will only last for 25 years at max. After 20 years lifespan, you’ll start to see a lot of wear and tear in the roof.

Most of the time, the wear and tear will be beyond repair.

2: Heavier:

Even though in recent years there has been a reduction in their weight, by using less base material, the asphalt shingle roofs are yet still heavier than the metal roofs.

Advantages – Metal Roof 

1: Light Weight:

One of the major benefits of metal roofing is that they are light in weight. Therefore, they are easier for the installers to carry up on the roof. Other than that, they won’t put unwanted stress on the structure of the building too.

2: Lower Cost:

Did you know that a perfectly installed metal roof can last up to more than 60 years? This makes the metal roof an economical choice when compared to the asphalt shingle roofs.

3: Fire Resistance:

The Metal roofs are classified as Class A fire-rate and non-combustible. This means that they are more resistant to catching fire. The metal roofs are most popular in areas that are prone to wildfires.

Disadvantage – Metal Roof 

1: Labor Intensive:

The metal roofs need to be installed by only professionals. This implies that they have to go under a labor-intensive process. Without a doubt, metal roof installation can take up a lot of time. You will always need to hire a best roofing contractor in such times.

2: Higher Installation Cost:

When it comes to metal roof cost, they are more expensive than the asphalt shingle roofs. Yes, the one-time installation cost of metal roofs is high. But on the bright side, the metal roofs ought to last more than 60 years which is why they are considered to be an economical choice.


Your roof will not only protect your house and the items inside it but will also keep you and your family safe. When it comes to choosing a roof, you should always consider all the factors and then make a sound decision.


What do you think?


Written by Justin Mark

Years Of Membership

Leave a Reply